Patrick M. Garry’s The Discovery encompasses a narrative that traverses a family legal case jigsaw puzzle toward a discovery of self by exploring the ghost of ancient regrets, basic human desires, and questions of faith.
Frank Horgan, a former lawyer at one of Minneapolis’ largest firms, now practices small-case litigation in the little community of Basswood Hills. Frank, a victim of his own follies, has one more chance to restore his career to its former glory. But not before a huge legal matter comes knocking on his door at his father’s diner. This case kicks off the legal drama, bringing in several main and secondary characters to play their parts in the ultimate discovery of buried contentedness and eventually a scandal that breaks into the national newspaper.
Meanwhile, Frank comes upon the case of the most prominent McCorkle family in Basswood Hills.
Clayton McCorkle made a contract nearly a decade ago for his children to own the McCorkle Farm Equipment Company. But now, Clayton wants to reclaim his business. As his lawyer, Frank must overturn the agreement in order to reclaim Clayton’s ownership of the company from the children. The McCorkle kids’ choice of a huge New York firm for representation causes Frank to dig deeper.
It seems that the kids’ are involved with the commodities hedge fund, Parnassis, which owns a bin site adjacent to McCorkle land, and is coincidentally, also represented by the same huge New York firm. Parnassis’s urgent involvement in the case as well as the McCorkle siblings’ sudden generosity in preserving a portion of factory land around the bin site as a nature preserve reinforce Frank’s belief that there is more to this story than meets the eye.
Frank confronts a dilemma.
Enter Emily, an ex-nun and Frank’s road to faith, who seeks funds for a social cause benefiting women. Only, the funds are contingent on Frank’s losing the McCorkle lawsuit. Frank, as Clayton’s lawyer, must not only contend with the big firm lawyer’s blackmailing and unethical practices, but confront rumors of bodies of Clayton immigrant workers buried twenty years ago at the McCorkle factory site. If that weren’t enough, Frank’s close friend, Martin, has his own set of reasons to weaken Frank’s victory in the case.
The omniscient third-person narration of the story is the correct choice, in that, it allows for the characters’ implicit dialogues to gain depth into their development. Patrick M. Garry cleverly utilizes a non-linear narrative, the incorporation of first-person accounts written by Frank Horgan’s acquaintances and former clients that adds a sense of urgency and character development of the protagonist.
A key theme in the novel is the nuanced relationship between moral emotions and behavior in human life.
Frank’s ego compels him to always want to be linked with the most important cases – and to win. His pride and lack of judgement propel him to act in such a way that his profession and goals become jeopardized. As for Emily, she has felt the sting of her own past actions that cause her to doubt her ultimate trust and optimism in life. The continual struggle with guilt, as well as the search for meaning in life, dominate the novel. This reinforces the recurring topic in this author’s novels – life and the struggle of human beings to live in ways that transcend basic materialism and the grasp of destructive temptations.
Infused with legal drama, religious themes, and a personal quest, The Discovery is an all-action adrenaline-filled novel readers’ won’t want to put down.
Patrick M. Garry won Grand Prize in 2021 CIBAs in the Mystery & Mayhem Division.
